MSP RMM vs PRTG

So, you’re caught in the middle of deciding between two powerful IT monitoring and management tools: MSP RMM solutions and PRTG Network Monitor. Both are industry giants but cater to different needs. MSP RMM (Remote Monitoring and Management) platforms are typically designed for Managed Service Providers, providing a wide range of remote management tools. On the other hand, PRTG (Paessler Router Traffic Grapher) is a comprehensive network monitoring solution favored by IT departments looking to keep a close eye on their infrastructure. Let’s dive deep into how these two stack up against each other.

MSP RMM vs. PRTG Network Monitor: The Detailed Comparison

We’ll break down this comparison based on user experience, core features, network monitoring capabilities, automation, security, integrations, pricing, and support. Whether you’re an MSP or an IT professional managing an internal network, this guide will help you choose the right tool for your needs.

1. User Interface and Experience

MSP RMM

  • Dashboard and Layout: MSP RMM tools such as Datto RMM, Kaseya VSA, or SolarWinds RMM typically have comprehensive dashboards with detailed reporting and management features.
  • Ease of Use: Depending on the platform, the learning curve can vary significantly. Some, like SolarWinds RMM, offer a more user-friendly experience, while others, like Kaseya, might require more training to use effectively.
  • Customization: Highly customizable with many ready-to-use templates, policies, and scripts to fit various environments. Tailored specifically for MSPs managing multiple clients.

PRTG Network Monitor

  • Dashboard and Layout: PRTG boasts a highly visual and interactive dashboard, providing a real-time overview of network health with color-coded status indicators (e.g., red for errors, green for healthy).
  • Ease of Use: PRTG is relatively easy to set up, and its UI is intuitive. The platform is more visual and straightforward, providing at-a-glance status for devices, servers, and network components.
  • Customization: Offers deep customization for dashboards, alerts, and sensors. IT teams can create customized maps and views to focus on specific areas of the network.

Verdict: For MSPs managing multiple client networks, MSP RMM platforms offer a more tailored experience. If you’re an IT admin looking for network visualization and ease of use within a single environment, PRTG shines.

2. Core Features and Capabilities

When it comes to features, MSP RMM and PRTG serve different purposes but have some overlapping capabilities.

Feature MSP RMM PRTG Network Monitor
Remote Monitoring Multi-tenant, endpoint management Network-focused, device and traffic monitoring
Patch Management Centralized, automated patching Not a core feature, requires external integration
Automation and Scripting Extensive scripting and automation for tasks Limited to automation scripts related to sensors
Network Monitoring Basic network monitoring tools Advanced, in-depth network monitoring
Reporting and Alerts Comprehensive, tailored to MSP needs Real-time alerts, customizable dashboards
Security and Compliance Endpoint security, compliance modules Network anomaly detection, SNMP monitoring

Remote Monitoring and Management

  • MSP RMM: Built to manage multiple environments, MSP RMM solutions provide a broader scope of remote monitoring, including endpoint management, patching, software deployment, and user support.
  • PRTG: Specializes in monitoring network devices, bandwidth, and overall network health. It excels at detecting network issues, monitoring server health, and visualizing traffic flows.

Automation and Scripting

  • MSP RMM: Offers robust scripting options for automation. You can deploy scripts across multiple clients or devices to automate repetitive tasks like software updates, antivirus scans, or system cleanups.
  • PRTG: Provides basic scripting capabilities to automate responses to certain network conditions. It’s more about creating automated alerts or actions when network anomalies are detected.

Verdict: If your primary focus is network monitoring and visualization, PRTG is unbeatable. For comprehensive IT management, patching, and multi-tenant capabilities, MSP RMM solutions are the way to go.

3. Network Monitoring and Performance Management

  • MSP RMM: Offers network monitoring as part of a larger suite of features. These tools typically provide basic network monitoring capabilities such as device status checks and simple SNMP monitoring.
  • PRTG: A specialist in network monitoring with deep, granular monitoring capabilities. It covers everything from traffic analysis, server monitoring, and bandwidth usage to SNMP traps and NetFlow analysis.

Verdict: If deep network insights are critical for your organization, PRTG Network Monitor is designed for this purpose and excels over typical MSP RMM tools.

4. Integration and Compatibility

Both platforms offer integrations but serve different purposes.

  • MSP RMM: Integrates deeply with other IT management tools like PSA (Professional Services Automation), backup solutions, antivirus, and other management tools. Ideal for creating an integrated stack for MSPs.
  • PRTG: Provides a range of integrations focused on expanding network monitoring capabilities, including cloud services (AWS, Azure), various databases, and virtual environments. It also has an API for further custom integrations.

Verdict: MSP RMM is more focused on a complete MSP toolkit, while PRTG focuses on enhancing network visibility with broad monitoring integrations.

5. Pricing and Licensing

Pricing can vary widely between these two types of platforms.

  • MSP RMM: Generally based on a per-device or per-endpoint model. The pricing can add up as you scale, but it’s designed to be flexible for MSPs managing multiple clients.
  • PRTG Network Monitor: Typically uses a sensor-based pricing model. You pay based on the number of sensors you need, where each sensor monitors a single aspect, like CPU usage or bandwidth on a port. The costs can be more predictable if you know your exact monitoring needs.

Verdict: PRTG might be more cost-effective for organizations with specific network monitoring needs. MSP RMM tools can be more cost-effective when managing a large number of clients and endpoints.

6. Customer Support and Community

  • MSP RMM: Support varies by vendor but generally offers dedicated support channels and an active community. The quality and responsiveness can differ widely.
  • PRTG Network Monitor: Known for its responsive customer support and a robust online community. Paessler provides extensive documentation and user forums for troubleshooting and learning.

Verdict: PRTG has a strong reputation for support and community engagement, whereas MSP RMM support quality can vary significantly between vendors.

Final Thoughts: Which Tool Is Right for You?

  • If you’re an MSP managing multiple clients with diverse IT environments, you need a tool that can handle everything from patch management to remote support. MSP RMM solutions like SolarWinds RMM, Datto RMM, or Kaseya VSA provide comprehensive tools to cover all these needs.
  • However, if you are an IT department or network administrator looking for an in-depth, real-time view of your network’s health, performance, and traffic, PRTG Network Monitor is the specialist tool built for the job. It offers the depth, granularity, and customizability needed for focused network monitoring.

Key Takeaway: Choose MSP RMM for all-around IT management across multiple clients or environments. Choose PRTG if network visibility and performance management are your top priorities.

Leave a Comment